← All workIndependent · Product owner and builder · 2026

idM

M let you compose by steering processes instead of writing notes. I rebuilt it from its manual alone: first in the browser, as M-Clone, then as idM, which ships as an AU, VST3, CLAP, standalone and browser app and is confirmed working in Ableton Live 12.

Who it’s forComposers and electronic musicians, in a browser or inside their DAW.

ProductAudioBuilt with AI
180manual capabilities, each a test
4 daysfirst commit to public alpha
5formats from one engine
13,225values matched across 3 compilers

The problem

  • M's way of composing, with variables, cyclic patterns, conducting and snapshots, has no modern equivalent.
  • It had to be faithful without copying a line of the original.
  • Musicians live in their DAW, so the composer had to run there, with real MIDI out.
  • Plugin hosts pass MIDI through a gate they control and never report. A working engine and a host ignoring it look the same.

What I did

  • Ran it as a clean room: the M 2.7 manual decides behavior, screenshots decide only layout.
  • Turned the manual into 180 numbered capabilities, each one a test. 163 pass and 17 are exclusions with a reason, checked on every build.
  • Shipped the browser version, M-Clone, as a free alpha four days after the first commit.
  • Merged 34 contradictory planning docs into one master plan with decisions of record.
  • Split the 5,711-line engine into its own library with no browser code, so it could ship as a plugin and run inside idMLab.
  • Made the plugin's C++ engine match the TypeScript one exactly: 13,225 values under clang, MSVC and GCC.
  • Ported the web interface into the plugin instead of redesigning it.
  • Ran a three-stage AI design review: clipped controls went from 17 to 0, and title contrast from 3.7:1 to over 5.6:1.

What changed

  • v0.8.0-alpha shipped first, as M-Clone: a single HTML file that opens with no install.
  • v0.9.0-alpha followed, as idM, for macOS, Windows and Linux.
  • Confirmed in Ableton Live 12. An outside tester reported it passing MIDI on Linux.
  • 3,471 automated tests on the browser version, and 921 on the plugin.
  • The engine now runs as a module inside idMLab.

Decisions

  • An instrument with MIDI out, never a MIDI-effect VST3.Ableton rejects that shape. The reasoning is cited to the line in the plugin framework.
  • Test the seam the user stands on.The AU looked dead in Ableton for three days while every test passed. I added a notes-sent counter and a virtual MIDI port.
  • Rust to C++, a day and a half in.The reason for Rust disappeared, so I reversed the engine language and wrote down why.
  • MIDI file import stays out.It stays out “unless a future workflow creates real user value”. The exclusion is written down with its reason.
Light theme. Every voice keeps its color in every window.
Light theme. Every voice keeps its color in every window.
The first version, M-Clone: the classic palette, with the built-in synth
The first version, M-Clone: the classic palette, with the built-in synth
Before the design review
Before the design review
After: no clipped controls
After: no clipped controls

Need a product manager who can also build?

Talk about a role